Implementing the HEVC standard in software
Challenges and Recommendations for organisations planning development and deployment of software
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.18757/jos.2022.6695Keywords:
HEVC, ITU-T H.265, ISO/IEC 23008-2, Open source software, Standard essential patents, Licence conditions, (F)RANDAbstract
Implementation and use of an IT standard in software involves legal, technical and societal challenges. This paper addresses how an organisation can, and should, determine the conditions for implementation and use of the HEVC standard in software. The investigation considers the availability of the standard’s complete technical specification and the extent to which an organisation can access the information necessary to assess the licence conditions for standard essential patents impinging on the standard. Through an action case study approach the investigation analyses declarations in patent databases relevant to the standard and seeks to obtain patent licences from each declarant permitting implementation of the standard in software, where that software is to be provided under one (or several) of three specific open source software licences, and alternatively to be provided as an online service. Our analysis of legal and licensing conditions for use of the standard shows significant obstacles. We find that it is impossible to obtain licences from patent holders that would allow for implementation and use of the standard in open source software. The paper illuminates significant challenges related to conditions for use of the standard under (F)RAND terms and identifies that references to the standard in public procurement projects lead to anti-competitive effects.
References
Advance (2021) HEVC Advance, Access Advance LLC, Boston, https://accessadvance.com/ (As is: 13 April 2021)
Bosworth, D. S., Mangum III, R. W. and Matolo, E. C. (2018) FRAND Commitments and Royalties for Standard Essential Patents, In Bharadwaj, A. et al. (Eds.) Complications and Quandaries in the ICT Sector: Standard Essential Patents and Competition Issues, Springer, Singapore, pp. 19-36. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-6011-3_2
Braa, K. and Vidgen, R. (1999) Interpretation, intervention, and reduction in the organizational laboratory: a framework for in-context information system research, Accounting, Management & Information Technology, Vol. 9(1), pp. 25-47.
Chiariglione, L. (2018) A crisis, the causes and a solution, Leonardo’s blog, 28 January, https://blog.chiariglione.org/a-crisis-the-causes-and-a-solution/
Choi, K., Chen, J, Rusanovskyy, D., Choi, K. and Jang, E. S. (2020) An Overview of the MPEG-5 Essential Video Coding Standard, IEEE Signal Processing Magazine, Vol. 37(3), pp. 160-167.
Contreras, J. L. (2016) Patents and Internet Standards, Centre for International Governance Innovation and Chatham House, Paper Series No. 29, 15 April. https://www.cigionline.org/sites/default/files/gcig_no29_web.pdf
EC (2014a) Patents and Standards: A modern framework for IPR-based standardization, Final report, A study prepared for the European Commission Directorate-General for Enterprise and Industry, 25 March, ISBN 978-92-79-35991-0, http://dx.doi.org/10.2769/90861
EC (2014b) Standard-essential patents, European Commission, Competition policy brief, Issue 8, June, ISBN 978-92-79-35553-0. http://ec.europa.eu/competition/publications
EC (2014c) Case at.39939 – Samsung – Enforcement of UMTS standard essential patents, Antitrust procedure: Council Regulation (EC) 1/2003, Commission Decision, 2891 final, 29 April.
Egyedi, T. M. (2016) On Technology Choice in Standardization: Implications for Patent Valuation, RECENT 49, Vol. 17(3), pp. 172-181 (also presented at the 13th International Conference “Standardization, Protypes and Quality: a Means of Balkan Countries’ Collaboration”, Brasov, Romania, 3-4 November 2016)
EWHC (2019) Vestel v HEVC Advance, EWHC 2766 (Ch), Case No: HP-2019-000008, Royal Courts of Justice, London, 21 October.
Geradin, D. (2013) Ten Years of DG Competition Effort to Provide Guidance on the Application of Competition Rules to the Licensing of Standard-Essential Patents: Where Do We Stand?, Research Roundtable on Innovation and Technology Standards, February 7-8, 2013, Searle Center on Law, Regulation, and Economic Growth, Northwestern University School of Law.
Glader, M. (2010) Open Standards: Public Policy Aspects and Competition Law Requirements, European Competition Journal, Vol. 6(3), pp. 611-648.
ISO (2021) ISO Standards and Patents, ISO, https://www.iso.org/iso-standards-and-patents.html (As is: 13 April 2021)
ISO (2022) Patent Statement and Licensing Declaration for ITU-T or ITU-R Recommendation | ISO or IEC Deliverable, ITU, ISO, IEC, http://isotc.iso.org/livelink/livelink/Open/6297442 (As is: 14 August 2022)
ITU (2013) High efficiency video coding, Recommendation ITU-T H.265 (04/2013), Edition 1.0, 13 April, International Telecommunication Union (ITU). https://www.itu.int/rec/T-REC-H.265-201304-S
ITU (2021a) Intellectual property rights (IPR) in ITU-T Recommendations, ITU,
https://www.itu.int/net4/ipr/search.aspx?sector=ITU-T&class=PS&rec=H.265&prod=H.265&opt=-1&field=anokwcvd (As is: 13 April 2021)
ITU (2021b) Joint Video Team (JVT), ITU, https://www.itu.int/en/ITU-T/studygroups/com16/video/Pages/jvt.aspx
ITU (2021c) JCT-VC - Joint Collaborative Team on Video Coding, ITU,
https://www.itu.int/en/ITU-T/studygroups/2017-2020/16/Pages/video/jctvc.aspx
ITU (2021d) JVET - Joint Video Experts Team
https://www.itu.int/en/ITU-T/studygroups/2017-2020/16/Pages/video/jvet.aspx
JCT (2010a) Meeting report of the first meeting of the Joint Collaborative Team on Video Coding (JCT-VC), Joint Collaborative Team on Video Coding (JCT-VC) of ITU-T SG16 WP3 and ISO/IEC JTC1/SC29/WG11, 1st Meeting, 15-23 April, Document: JCTVC-A200.
JCT (2010b) Meeting report of the second meeting of the Joint Collaborative Team on Video Coding (JCT-VC), Joint Collaborative Team on Video Coding (JCT-VC) of ITU-T SG16 WP3 and ISO/IEC JTC1/SC29/WG11, 2nd Meeting, 21-28 July, Document: JCTVC-B200.
JCT (2010c) Ad hoc group report: JCT-VC project management, Joint Collaborative Team on Video Coding (JCT-VC) of ITU-T SG16 WP3 and ISO/IEC JTC1/SC29/WG11, 2nd Meeting, 21-28 July, Document: JCTVC-B201.
JCT (2010d) Meeting report of the third meeting of the Joint Collaborative Team on Video Coding (JCT-VC), Joint Collaborative Team on Video Coding (JCT-VC) of ITU-T SG16 WP3 and ISO/IEC JTC1/SC29/WG11, 3rd Meeting, 7-15 October, Document: JCTVC-C400.
JCT (2011a) Meeting report of the fifth meeting of the Joint Collaborative Team on Video Coding (JCT-VC), Joint Collaborative Team on Video Coding (JCT-VC) of ITU-T SG16 WP3 and ISO/IEC JTC1/SC29/WG11, 5th Meeting, 16-23 March, Document: JCTVC-E600v3.
JCT (2011b) Ad hoc group report: JCT-VC project management, Joint Collaborative Team on Video Coding (JCT-VC) of ITU-T SG16 WP3 and ISO/IEC JTC1/SC29/WG11, 5th Meeting, 16-23 March, Document: JCTVC-E001.
JCT (2020) Deployment status of the HEVC standard, Joint Collaborative Team on Video Coding (JCT-VC) of ITU-T SG 16 WP 3 and ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG 11, 40th Meeting, 24 June-1 July 2020, Document: JCTVC-AN0020-v2.
Jurata, J. and Luken, E. (2020) Glory Days: Do the Anticompetitive Risks of Standards-Essential Patent Pools Outweigh Their Procompetitive Benefits?, San Diego Law Review, Vol. 58(2), Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3622615
Kerdranvat, M., Chen, Y., Jullian, R., Galpin, F. and François, E. (2020) The Video Codec Landscape in 2020, ITU Journal: ICT Discoveries, Vol. 3(1), pp. 73-83.
Klos, M. (2020) Licence offers of HEVC Advance video pool are FRAND, rules Düsseldorf court, Juve Patent, 8 June, https://www.juve-patent.com/news-and-stories/cases/licence-offers-of-hevc-video-pool-are-frand-rules-dusseldorf-court/
Lim, D. (2015) Standard Essential Patents, Trolls, and the Smartphone Wars: Triangulating the End Game, Penn State Law Review, Vol. 119(1), pp. 1-91.
Lundell, B., Gamalielsson, J. and Katz, A. (2015) On implementation of Open Standards in software: To what extent can ISO standards be implemented in open source software?, International Journal of Standardization Research, Vol. 13(1), pp. 47-73.
Lundell, B., Gamalielsson, J. and Katz, A. (2019) Implementing IT Standards in Software: Challenges and Recommendations for Organisations Planning Software Development Covering IT Standards, European Journal of Law and Technology, Vol. 10(2). https://ejlt.org/index.php/ejlt/article/view/709/
Lundell, B., Gamalielsson, J., Katz, A. & Lindroth, M. (2021) Perceived and Actual Lock-in Effects Amongst Swedish Public Sector Organisations when Using a SaaS Solution, In Scholl, H. J. et al. (Eds.) EGOV 2021: Electronic Government, Lecture Notes in Computer Science, Vol. 12850, Springer, Cham, pp. 59-72. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-84789-0_5
Maldonado, K. (2014) Breaching RAND and Reaching for Reasonable: Microsoft v. Motorola and Standard-Essential Patent Litigation, Berkeley Technology Law Journal, Vol. 29(4), pp. 419-464.
MPEGLA (2014a) MPEG LA Offers HEVC Patent Portfolio License, MPEG LA, 29 September,
http://web.archive.org/web/20141009020633/http://www.mpegla.com/main/Pages/Media.aspx
MPEGLA (2014b) HEVC Attachment 1, MPEG LA, 1 December,
MPEGLA (2021) MPEG LA’s HEVC Patent Portfolio License, MPEG LA, Denver,
https://www.mpegla.com/programs/hevc/license-agreement/ (As is: 13 April 2021)
Oliver, E. and Richardson, K. (2018) What will TV cost you? Putting a price on HEVC licences, www.IAM-media.com, May/June, pp. 36-46.
OSD (2022) The Open Source Definition, Open Source Initiative, Version 1.9, 22 March 2007,
https://opensource.org/osd (As is: 13 August 2022).
OSI (2022) Open Source Initiative, https://opensource.org/ (As is: 19 August 2022).
OST (2019) Online Services Terms: June 1, 2019, Volume Licensing, Microsoft,
https://www.microsoftvolumelicensing.com/Downloader.aspx?DocumentId=15154
OST (2020) Online Services Terms: June 2020, Volume Licensing, Microsoft,
https://www.microsoftvolumelicensing.com/Downloader.aspx?DocumentId=17715
OST (2021) Online Services Terms: February 2021, Volume Licensing, Microsoft,
https://www.microsoftvolumelicensing.com/Downloader.aspx?DocumentId=18738
Pentheroudakis, C. and Baron, J. A. (2017) Licensing Terms of Standard Essential Patents: A Comprehensive Analysis of Cases, JRC Science for Policy Report, European Commission, Joint Research Centre, ISBN 978-92-79-64459-7, ISSN 1018-5593.
Régibeau, P., De Coninck, R. and Zenger, H. (2016) Transparency, Predictability, and Efficiency of SSO-based Standardization and SEP Licensing: A Report for the European Commission, Prepared for the Executive Agency for Small and medium-sized enterprises on behalf of the European Commission as part of Specific Contract No 07/2015 Implementing Framework Contract No MARKT/2011/022/B2/ST/FC, Ref. Ares(2016)6908173 – 12/12/2016, Charles River Associates, June.
Richter, K. (2020) HEVC Advance members sue Xiaomi and Vestel after MAS Elektronik success, Juve Patent, 31 August,
https://www.juve-patent.com/news-and-stories/cases/hevc-advance-members-sue-xiaomi-and-vestel/
Schindler, J. (2021) Qualcomm ends participation in HEVC licensing platform Velos Media, IAM Media, www.IAM-media.com, 28 September.
https://www.iam-media.com/article/qualcomm-ends-participation-in-hevc-licensing-platform-velos-media
Shapiro, C. (2000) Navigating the Patent Thicket: Cross Licenses, Patent Pools, and Standard Setting, In Jaffe, A. B., Lerner, J. and Stern, S. (Eds.) Innovation Policy and the Economy, Volume 1, The MIT Press, Massachusetts, pp. 119-150.
Sullivan, G. J., Ohm, J.-R., Han, W.-J. and Wiegand, T. (2012) Overview of the High Efficiency Video Coding (HEVC) Standard, IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems for Video Technology, Vol. 22(12), pp. 1649-1668.
SVT (2021) SVT Play: Teknisk information, Sveriges Television (SVT), the Swedish public service television company, Accessed 13 April 2021.
https://kontakt.svt.se/guide/teknisk-information (last update 23 June 2020).
Velos (2021) VELOS Media, Dallas, http://velosmedia.com (As is: 13 April 2021)
Wilson, K. S. (2018) Designing A Standard Essential Patent (SEP) Program, les Nouvelles: Journal of the Licensing Executives Society International, Vol. LIII(3), September, pp. 202-209. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3212735
Zhang, T. and Mao, S. (2018) An Overview of Emerging Video Coding Standards, GetMobile, Vol. 22(4), pp. 13-20.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Björn Lundell
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
